United Nations and United Nations Development Programme v. Lopes

Full Case Title: United Nations and United Nations Development Programme v. Carlos Antônio Branco Lopes, Federal Supreme Court, judgment of 31 August 2018

Reference Number: RE 1085624 / MT

Type of Document: Judicial decisions

International Organization: United Nations, UNDP

Year: 2018

Issuing Body: Supreme Court

Country: Brazil

Download PDF

The case originated from an employment dispute instituted against the United Nations and the United Nations Development Programme before Brazilian judicial authorities. On first instance, the Labour Court ruled upon the case, holding that States and international organizations are not entitled to absolute immunity under international law. According to this reasoning, labour disputes would fall out of the scope of international organizations’ immunity, limited to public or institutional acts.

The United Nations and UNDP appealed the judgment before the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court upheld the appeal, finding that the United Nations and its specialized agencies enjoy immunity from every legal process, except insofar as the organization waived such immunity, pursuant to the Convention on Privileges and Immunities of the United Nations and the Convention on Privileges of the Specialized Agencies. The Supreme Court reminded that such absolute immunity includes employment – related claims.