Sienra Castellanos, Félix, et al. v. Postal Union of Americas, Spain and Portugal

Full Case Title: Sienra Castellanos, Félix, et al. v. Unión Postal de las Américas, España y Portugal- U.P.A.E.P. – Cobro de pesos y daños y perjuicios – CAUSA DIPLOMATICA, Supreme Court, Judgment 2.440/2010, 24 December 2010

Reference Number: 1-100/2009

Type of Document: Judicial decisions

International Organization: PUASP

Year: 2010

Issuing Body: Supreme Court

Country: Uruguay

Download PDF

A group of retired former employees of Postal Union of Americas, Spain and Portugal (PUASP), an international organization headquartered in Uruguay, brought a claim before the Uruguayan Supreme Court seeking payment of pension arrears and damages.

The dispute arose from a resolution adopted by the XIX Congress of PUASP, which unilaterally reduced pension payments. The claimants had previously exhausted internal remedies without success, and argued that UPAEP had failed to establish any adequate alternative dispute settlement mechanism as required by Article 2 of its Headquarters Agreement with Uruguay.

The Supreme Court, by majority, upheld PUASP’s immunity from jurisdiction, grounding its decision in Article 2 of the 1981 Headquarters Agreement between Uruguay and the organization, which confers immunity from jurisdiction on the organization and its assets, unless immunity is expressly waived. Since no express waiver had been made, the Court found itself without jurisdiction to hear the case and declined to examine the merits of the dispute.

The Court also noted that the contested resolution could be characterized as an acta iure imperi and therefore fully covered by immunity. Accordingly, the Court declared that the organization enjoyed jurisdictional immunity and that proceedings could not continue before it.