N.A. v. African Union

Full Case Title: Brussels Labourt Court, N.A. v. African Union, No. 16/7777/A, 10 January 2018

Reference Number: Case No. 16/7777/A

Type of Document: Judicial decisions

International Organization: African Union

Year: 2018

Issuing Body: District Court/ Tribunal of first instance

Country: Belgium

Download PDF

A former employee of the Permanent Mission of the African Union in Brussels filed a lawsuit in the Brussels Labour Court against the African Unioni, complaining the termination of his employment.

The Labour Court dismissed the case, finding that the African Union is immune from legal process before Belgian courts pursuant to the Headquarters Agreement concluded in 1985 between the African Union and Belgium.

In this regards, the Court stressed that the immunity of international organization does not rest on a customary rule of international law. By contrast, the privileges and immunities of international organizations must be established in specific treaty provisions. As a result, the scope of international organizations’ immunities must be determined in light of such provisions. In the instant case, the Court found that the Headquarters Agreement conferred on the African Union immunity from all types of employment disputes.

The Court also held that the recognition of African Union’s immunity did not entail an unlawful restriction of the applicant’s right to a legal remedy. In this regard, the Court underlined that Belgian Court adhere to the approach elaborated by the European Court on Human Rights in the case Waite and Kennedy: the recognition of the jurisdictional immunity of an international organization is consistent with the obligations deriving from Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) to the extent that such organization had provided alternative and appropriate modes of dispute settlement. However, as it emphasized, Article 6  ECHR is not relevant in the instant case. The African Union and its members States are not parties to the ECHR.

Beside the above, the Court also underlined that applicant was not deprived of any mean of redress. As highlighted by the Court, the respondent organization had established an internal system of justice. In particular, the applicant had the possibility to file his complain before the African Union Administrative Tribunal. As assessed by the Court, the jurisdiction of the African Union Administrative Tribunal offers an effective judicial protection.