Londoño v. United Nations Development Programme
Full Case Title: Fernández de Soto Londoño v. United Nations Development Programme, Constitutional Court, Judgment of 13 October 2005
Reference Number: T-1029/05
Type of Document: Judicial decisions
International Organization: UNDP
Year: 2005
Issuing Body: Constitutional Court
Country: Colombia
The applicant filed a legal action against UNDP for alleged violation of the right to petition, based on the international organization’s refusal to provide certified copies of the bids submitted in the tender procedure administered by the municipality of Bogota and the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP). The Court of first instance and the Court of Appeal dismissed the action, finding that UNDP enjoyed immunity from jurisdiction. Therefore, the applicant brought an action before the Constitutional Court, alleging that the immunity granted to UNDP had violated his right to judicial protection.
The Constitutional Court underlined that Article IX of the Cooperation Agreement provides that UNDP shall enjoy in Brazil the privileges and immunities established in the Convention on Privileges and Immunities of the United Nations. Accordingly, UNDP would be immune from every legal process.
However, the Court reminded that, according its well established case-law, jurisdictional immunity of international organizations cannot be absolute. Under this view, granting absolute immunity would entail a complete erosion of the powers of a sovereign State to ensure the protection of the rights of persons under its jurisdiction. In particular, it affirmed that in the event that a legal dispute arises between a resident in Colombia and international organization, “the judicial mechanisms established by the national and international legal system may be used to resolve the conflict according to the rules in force in the national territory”.
Therefore, in the absence of dispute resolution mechanisms provided by the organization, national courts may exercise their jurisdiction over cases brought by Colombian citizens and residents in order to ensure the protection of the right to legal protection and to remedy.
However, the Court found that in the present case the applicant could have advanced his legal claims against the municipality of Bogotá. As a result, it dismissed the case.

