Fonseca v. United Nations

Full Case Title: Ana Cristina Fonseca v. United Nations, Federal Supreme Court, judgment of 19 April 2017

Reference Number: ARE 1038039 / MT

Type of Document: Judicial decisions

International Organization: United Nations

Year: 2017

Issuing Body: Supreme Court

Country: Brazil

Download PDF

The case originated from an employment dispute instituted before Brazilian judicial authorities by Ms Fonseca.

The Supreme Court dismissed the case, finding that national courts lack jurisdiction to hear claims against the United Nations. The Supreme Court stressed that, according to its traditional understanding, treaty-based jurisdictional immunity shields international organizations from any type of legal process, including employment dispute. As it underlined, the absolute immunity of the United Nations is established by the Convention on Privileges and Immunities of the United Nations, ratified by Brazil by virtue of Decree 784/50. Absent an express declaration of constitutional illegitimacy, national tribunals must apply the domestic provisions implementing international agreements to which Brazil is a party.